Factors Influencing Hospital Emergency Evacuation during Fire: A Systematic Literature Review

Ali Sahebi, Katayoun Jahangiri, Ahmad Alibabaei, Davoud Khorasani‑Zavareh

Abstract


Background: Although the hospital is known as a safe place for treating patients, due to various reasons, it is prone to several internal hazards, including fire. This study aimed to identify the factors affecting hospital emergency evacuation during fire. Methods: This was a systematic review conducted according to the PRISMA guideline. Thematic Content analysis was utilized to analyze and extract results. We found the studies investigating the factors affecting hospital emergency evacuation during fire through a comprehensive search in various data resources (MEDLINE, Web of Science, Google Scholar, Embase, ProQuest, Scopus, IRANMEDEX, SID, ISC, and Magiran) and other sources from the beginning of January 2000 to the end of December 2019. Thematic Content analysis was also employed to analyze. Results: At first and based on the initial search, 4484 studies were identified, and 48 articles were finally included in the study. Based on the results; five main themes along with 10 sub‑themes were identified. The themes included the incident’s characteristics, response measures, hospital preparedness, hospital residents, and hospital building, and the sub‑themes were emergency evacuation features, fire characteristics, command, operation, patients’ and staff’s characteristics, planning, logistics, and structure and design hospital. Conclusions: Based on the results of the present study, hospital preparedness as one of the most important factors can reduce the hospital evacuation time. Therefore, hospitals can ensure a timely and more effective response in emergency evacuation during fire by improving their preparedness.

Keywords


Disasters; emergencies; emergency evacuation; fire; hospitals

Full Text:

PDF

References


Sandra K, Meital N, Ofer M, Limor AD, Sara G, Bruria A.

Facilitating emergency hospital evacuation through uniform

discharge criteria. Am J Emerg Med 2017;35:681‑4.

Kazemzadeh M, Shafiei E, Jahangiri K, Yousefi K, Sahebi A. The

preparedness of hospital emergency departments for responding

to disasters in Iran; A systematic review and meta‑analysis. Arch

Acad Emerg Med 2019;7:e58.

Nasr Isfahani M, Davari F, Azizkhani R, Rezvani M. Decreased

emergency department overcrowding by discharge lounge:

A computer simulation study. Int J Prev Med 2020;11:13.

Iserson KV. Vertical hospital evacuations: A new method. South Med J 2013;106:37‑42.

Jang JH, Cho J‑S, Lim YS, Hyun SY, Woo J‑H, Choi WS, et al.

Disaster response to a mass casualty incident in a hospital fire

by regional disaster medical assistance team: Characteristics of

hospital fire. Disaster Med Public Health Prep 2020:1‑4. doi:

1017/dmp. 2020.164.

Boonngam H, Patvichaichod S. Fire evacuation and patient

assistance simulation in a large hospital building. IOP Conference

Series: Materials Science and Engineering. United Kingdom:

IOP Publishing: 2020.

Sharma A, Mace S. Reviewing disasters: Hospital evacuations

in the United States from 2000 to 2017. Prehosp Disaster Med

;34(s1):s22.

Shafiei E, Yousefi K, Sahebi A. Lessons learned; Hospital

emergency evacuation in Ilam, Iran. Trauma Mon 2019;24:3‑4.

Benesova S, Bradacova I, Jager T. Evacuation of persons

from selected departments in high‑rise buildings of healthcare

facilities. Commun Sci Lett Univ Zilina 2016;18:117‑22.

Huang D, Lo S, Yang L, Gao L, Lo JT, editors. Hospital

evacuation under fire: Risk identification and future prospect.

9th International Conference on Fire Science and Fire

Protection Engineering (ICFSFPE). Chengdu, China: IEEE:

Noh J, Chung HS, Jin HM, Hur J, Kim MJ, Kang CM, et al.

Tabletop simulation exercise of critically ill patient evacuation

from a hospital fire. Prehosp Disaster Med 2019;34(s1):s171.

Bagaria J, Heggie C, Abrahams J, Murray V. Evacuation and

sheltering of hospitals in emergencies: A review of international

experience. Prehosp Disaster Med 2009;24:461‑7.

Hunt AL, Galea ER, Lawrence PJ, Frost IR, Gwynne SM.

Simulating movement devices used in hospital evacuation. Fire

Technol 2020;56:2209‑40.

Poppenborg J, Knust S. Modeling and optimizing the evacuation

of hospitals based on the MRCPSP with resource transfers.

EURO J Comput Optim 2016;4:349‑80.

Golmohammadi D, Shimshak D. Estimation of the evacuation

time in an emergency situation in hospitals. Comput Ind Eng

;61:1256‑67.

Tekin E, Bayramoglu A, Uzkeser M, Cakir Z. Evacuation of

hospitals during disaster, establishment of a field hospital, and

communication. Eurasian J Med 2017;49:137‑41.

Akıncıtürk N. An evaluation of hospital evacuation strategies

with an example. Int J Appl 2015;5.

Yaghoubi T, Ardalan A, Khorasani Zavareh D, Khankeh H,

Nejati A, Ebadi A. Decisionmaking on hospital emergency

evacuation in disasters and emergencies: Findings from a

systematic review. Iran Red Crescent Med J 2017;19:e14214.

Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. Preferred reporting

items for systematic reviews and meta‑analyses: The PRISMA

statement. PLoS Med 2009;6:e1000097.

Maguire M, Delahunt B. Doing a thematic analysis: A practical,

step‑by‑step guide for learning and teaching scholars. All Ireland

J Higher Educ 2017;9.

Curti S, Gori D, Di Gregori V, Farioli A, Baldasseroni A,

Fantini MP, et al. PubMed search filters for the study of putative

outdoor air pollution determinants of disease. BMJ Open

;6:e013092.

White RG, Hakim AJ, Salganik MJ, Spiller MW, Johnston LG,

Kerr L, et al. Strengthening the reporting of observational

studies in epidemiology for respondent‑driven sampling

studies: “STROBE‑RDS” statement. J Clin Epidemiol

;68:1463‑71.

Venkataseshan J, Pandit S, Saini A. Fire accidents in neonatal

nursery: Prevention and management. Indian J Pediatr

;78:1404‑6.

Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D; CONSORT Group.

CONSORT 2010 statement: Updated guidelines for reporting

parallel group randomised trials. Trials 2010;11:32.

Alonso‑Gutierrez V, Cuesta A, Alvear D, Lázaro M. The impact

of a change on the size of the smoke compartment in the

evacuation of health care facilities. Fire Technol 2018;54:335‑54.

Alonso-Gutierrez V, Ronchi E. The simulation of assisted

evacuation in hospitals. InFire and Evacuation Modelling

Technical Conference. Torremolinos, Spain, Torremolinos:2016.

Carey MG. Smoked out: Emergency evacuation of an ICU. Am J

Nurs 2007;107:54‑7.

Catovic L, Alniemi C, Ronchi E, editors. A survey on the factors

affecting horizontal assisted evacuation in hospitals. Journal of

Physics: Conference Series. Nancy, France: IOP Publishing:

De‑Ching H, Shen‑Wen C, Chien‑Hung L, Po‑Ta H, Yi‑Ting S,

Huei‑Ru S. A study for the evacuation of hospital on fire during

construction. Procedia Eng 2011;11:139‑46.

Dhaliwal N, Bhogal RS, Kumar A, Gupta AK. Responding to

fire in an intensive care unit: Management and lessons learned.

World J Emerg Med 2018;9:154‑6.

Femino M, Young S, Smith VC. Hospital‑based emergency

preparedness evacuation of the neonatal intensive care unit‑the

smallest and most vulnerable population. Pediatr Emerg Care

;29:107‑13.

Gildea JR, Etengoff S. Vertical evacuation simulation of critically

ill patients in a hospital. Prehosp Disaster Med 2005;20:243‑8.

Gretenkort P, Harke H, Blazejak J, Pache B, Leledakis G. Interface

between hospital and fire authorities‑A concept for management of

incidents in hospitals. Prehosp Disaster Med 2002;17:42‑7.

Hogan C. Responding to a fire at a pediatric hospital. AORN J

;75:793‑6.

Hoondert P. State of the art fire safety concept for evacuation of

different types of vulnerable patients in Dutch hospitals: Specific

egress times for different groups of (vunerable) hospital patients:

Delft University of Technology Faculty of Architecture and the

Built Environment Building Technology: FELLOW/fse:2017.

Hunt A, Galea ER, Lawrence PJ. An analysis and numerical

simulation of the performance of trained hospital staff using

movement assist devices to evacuate people with reduced

mobility. Fire Mater 2015;39:407‑29.

Iadanza E, Luschi A, Merli T, Terzaghi F, editors. Navigation

Algorithm for the Evacuation of Hospitalized Patients.

Singapore: Springer Singapore; 2019.

Jafari M. Evacuation planning and emergency management study

of Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital. Rutgers University

Center for Advanced Infrastructure and Transportation; 2005.

Johnson D, Luscombe M, Groves J. Evacuation of an intensive

care unit after a fire. Media War Confl 2007;8:14‑6.

Kelly FE, Hardy R, Cook TM, Nolan JP, Craft T, Osborn M,

et al. Managing the aftermath of a fire on intensive care caused

by an oxygen cylinder. J Intensive Care Soc 2014;15:283‑7.

Lee PH, Fu B, Cai W, Chen J, Yuan Z, Zhang L, et al.

The effectiveness of an on‑line training program for

improving knowledge of fire prevention and evacuation of

healthcare workers: A randomized controlled trial. PLoS One

;13:e0199747.

Löfqvist E, Oskarsson Å, Brändström H, Vuorio A, Haney M.

Evacuation preparedness in the event of fire in intensive

care units in Sweden: More is needed. Prehosp Disaster Med

;32:317‑20.

Manion P, Golden IJ. Vertical evacuation drill of an intensive

care unit: Design, implementation, and evaluation. Disaster

Manag Response 2004;2:14‑9.

McCarthy PM, Gaucher KA. Fire in the OR—Developing a fire

safety plan. AORN J 2004;79:587‑600.

Murphy GRF, Foot C. ICU fire evacuation preparedness in

London: A cross‑sectional study. Br J Anaesth 2011;106:695‑8.

Rahouti A, Datoussaid S, Lovreglio R. A sensitivity analysis

of a hospital evacuation in case of fire. InFire and Evacuation

Modelling Technical Conference.Malaga, Spain: Semantic

Scholar;2016.

Rispoli F, Iannuzzi M, De Robertis E, Piazza O, Servillo G,

Tufano R. Warning! fire in the ICU. Prehosp Disaster Med

;29:339‑40.

Samoshin DA, Istratov RN. The parameters of pedestrian

flows in hospital during fire evacuation. Proceedings of 13th

International Conference "Interflam 2013”. Royal Holloway

College, University of London, UK:2013.

Tzeng HM, Yin CY. Environment of care: vertical evacuation

concerns for acutely ill patients and others with restricted

mobility. InNursing forum 2014;49:209-12.

Wei X, Lv W, Song W, Wang D. Evacuation analysis of a

hospital based on fds+ evac software. 2011 International

Conference on Remote Sensing, Environment and Transportation

Engineering. Nanjing, China: EEE: 2011.

Wigmore T. Evacuation of the ICU due to fire. J Intensive Care

Soc 2014;15:281‑2.

Yokouchi M, Hasegawa Y, Sasaki R, Gaku R, Murata Y,

Mizuno N, et al. Operations analysis of hospital ward evacuation

using crowd density model with occupancy area and velocity by

patient type. In2017 Winter Simulation Conference: IEEE:2017.

Zhang W, Yao Z, editors. A reformed lattice gas model and its

application in the simulation of evacuation in hospital fire. 2010

IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and

Engineering Management; IEEE: 2010.

Zhang G, Li C, Lu S, editors. Analysis of Fire Evacuation in

Highrise Hospitals from a Highrise Hospital Fire Case. 2019

th International Conference on Fire Science and Fire Protection

Engineering (ICFSFPE). Chengdu, China:IEEE:2019.

Bongiovanni I, Leo E, Ritrovato M, Santoro A, Derrico P.

Implementation of best practices for emergency response and

recovery at a large hospital: A fire emergency case study. Saf Sci

;96:121‑31.

Uehara S, Tomomatsu K. Evacuation simulation system

considering evacuee profiles and spatial characteristics. Fire Saf

Sci 2003;7:963‑74.

Ahmadzadeh F, Shokri M. Investigation of factors affecting

to emergency evacuation of medical centers in emergency

conditions and disaster preparedness, A case study. Fire incident

in Takhte Jamshid hospital of Alborz province. 4th Comprehensive

Conference on Disaster Management & HSE; Tehran university:

Permanent Secretariat of the Conference: CIVILICA: 2017.

[persian].

D’Orazio M, Bernardini G, Longhi S, Olivetti P. Evacuation aid

for elderly in care homes and hospitals: An interactive system for

reducing pre‑movement time in case of fire. Ambient Assisted

Living: Springer; 2015. p. 169‑78.

Gupta S. A Machine Learning based Path Guidance System

for Safe Evacuation of a Hospital Building in Case of Fire.

Kharagpur: Indian Institute of Technology; 2019.

Gwynne S, Galea E, Parke J, Hickson J. The collection and

analysis of pre‑evacuation times derived from evacuation trials

and their application to evacuation modelling. Fire Technol

;39:173‑95.

Liu S, Lv C, Guo J. Crowd Evacuation Simulation of a SingleFloor Building Based on Multimode Evacuation Ways. Fourth

International Conference on Transportation Engineering.

Chengdu, China: ASCE Library: 2013.

Loria G, Choudhry N, Sharma K. Fire management in hospitals.

Apollo Med 2012;9:74‑6.

Shastri BA, Raghav YS, Sahadev R, Yadav BP. Analysis of Fire

Protection Facilities in Hospital Buildings. Advances in Fire and

Process Safety.Singapore, Springer. 2018.

Silva JF, Almeida JE, Rossetti RJ, Coelho AL. A serious

game for EVAcuation training. In2013 IEEE 2nd International

Conference on Serious Games and Applications for Health

(SeGAH). Vilamoura, Portugal: IEEE: 2013.

Johnson CW. The Glasgow-hospital evacuation simulator: Using

computer simulations to support a risk-based approach for

hospital evacuation. Technical report. University of Glasgow;

P.18.

Wei‑Wen T, Kuo‑Hsiung P, Che‑Ming H. Performance‑based fire

safety design for existing small‑scale hospitals. Procedia Eng

;11:514‑21.

Jiang ZM, Zhang PH, Shang RX, Tian XL. Investigation and

simulation on human evacuation behaviour in large hospital

building in Shenyang. Procedia Eng 2014;71:101‑6.

Acar YA, Mehta N, Rich M‑A, Yilmaz BK, Careskey M,

Generoso J, et al. Using standardized checklists increase the

completion rate of critical actions in an evacuation from the

operating room: A randomized controlled simulation study.

Prehosp Disaster Med 2019;34:393‑400.

Yang P, Li C, Chen D. Fire emergency evacuation simulation

based on integrated fire–evacuation model with discrete design

method. Adv Eng Softw 2013;65:101‑11.

Rahmani A, Salem M. Simulation of fire in super high‑rise

hospitals using fire dynamics simulator (FDS). Electron J Gen

Med 2020;17:em200.

Nguyen MH, Ho TV, Zucker J‑D. Integration of smoke effect

and blind evacuation strategy (SEBES) within fire evacuation

simulation. Simul Model Pract Theory 2013;36:44‑59.

Augustine J, Schoettmer JT. Evacuation of a rural community

hospital: Lessons learned from an unplanned event. Disaster

Manag Response 2005;3:68‑72.

King MA, Dorfman MV, Einav S, Niven AS, Kissoon N,

Grissom CK. Evacuation of intensive care units during disaster:

Learning from the Hurricane Sandy experience. Disaster Med

Public Health Prep 2016;10:20‑7.

Balikuddembe JK, Ardalan A, Khorasani‑Zavareh D, Nejati A,

Kasiima S. Factors affecting the exposure, vulnerability and

emergency medical service capacity for victims of road traffic

incidents in Kampala Metropolitan Area: A Delphi study. BMC

Emerg Med 2016;17:1.

Balikuddembe JK, Ardalan A, Khorasani‑Zavareh D, Nejati A,

Raza O. Weaknesses and capacities affecting the Prehospital

emergency care for victims of road traffic incidents in the greater

Kampala metropolitan area: A cross‑sectional study. BMC Emerg

Med 2017;17:29.

Hicks J, Glick R. A meta-analysis of hospital evacuations:

Overcoming barriers to effective planning. J Healthc Risk Manag

;34:26‑36.

Kolifarhood G, Khorasani‑Zavareh D, Salarilak S, Shoghli A,

Khosravi N. Spatial and non‑spatial determinants of successful

tuberculosis treatment outcomes: An implication of Geographical

Information Systems in health policy‑making in a developing

country. J Epidemiol Glob Health 2015;5:221‑30.

Petinaux B, Yadav K. Patient‑driven resource planning of a health

care facility evacuation. Prehosp Disaster Med 2013;28:120‑6.

Rahouti A, Lovreglio R, Jackson P, Datoussaïd S. Evacuation

data from a hospital outpatient drill the case study of North

Shore Hospital. Collect Dyn 2020;5:142‑9.

Sadeghi‑Bazargani H, Abedi L, Mahini M, Amiri S,

Khorasani‑Zavareh D. Adult attention‑deficit hyperactivity

disorder, risky behaviors, and motorcycle injuries: A case‑control

study. Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat 2015;7:2049‑54.

Sharma R, Kumar A, Koushal V. Response to a fire incident

in the operation room: A cautionary tale. Disaster Med Public

Health Prep 2020;14:284‑8.

Davudian Talab A, Azari G, Badfar G, Kiani H, Parvin S.

Effectiveness of safety training on knowledge and practice of

operating room personnel regarding fire prevention. Int J Hosp

Res 2017;6:14‑8.

Bajow NA, Alkhalil SM. Evaluation and analysis of hospital

disaster preparedness in Jeddah. Health 2014;6:2668.

Kreinin A, Shakera T, Sheinkman A, Levi T, Tal V, Polakiewicz J.

Evacuation of a mental health center during a forest fire in Israel.

Disaster Med Public Health Prep 2014;8:288‑92.

Rozenfeld RA, Reynolds SL, Ewing S, Crulcich MM,

Stephenson M. Development of an evacuation tool to

facilitate disaster preparedness: Use in a planned evacuation

to support a hospital move. Disaster Med Public Health Prep

;11:479‑86.

Rabbani M, Zhalechian M, Farshbaf-Geranmayeh A. A robust

possibilistic programming approach to multiperiod hospital

evacuation planning problem under uncertainty. Int Trans Operat

Res 2018;25:157‑89.