Healthcare System Responsiveness in Covid‑19: An Experience from Capital City of I.R of Iran

Ameneh Setareh Forouzan, Arash Mirabzadeh, Katayoun Falahat, Zahra Banazadeh, Monir Baradaran Eftekhari

Abstract


Background: As a public health emergency, coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid‑19) is a threat to our future; therefore, appropriate health system responsiveness (HSR), as an important criterion, is of crucial importance. This study aimed to evaluate the different dimensions of responsiveness of healthcare centers, both public and private, providing COVID‑19 services in Tehran. Methods: Following a cross‑sectional design, this study was conducted in Tehran (the capital city of I.R. Iran) from May to November 2020. Data were collected using the World Health Organization (WHO) questionnaire on responsiveness. Two hundred questionnaires were filled out through face‑to‑face or phone call interviews in two public and private hospitals (100 in each) providing Covid‑19 services. Participants were selected using the convenience sampling technique among all those who received Covid‑19 services during the past six months in the city of Tehran. Results: The mean age of participants was 45.9 ± 15.9 and 51.5% were female. On an average, 52.6% of the respondents evaluated at least one dimension of responsiveness as appropriate and/or strongly appropriate. Communication obtained the highest score (58.2%), followed by confidentiality (56.5%), dignity (56%), and prompt attention (52%). Meanwhile, autonomy and choice were evaluated as poor (moderate, weak, and strongly weak) by 63.5 and 52.5% of respondents. There was no significant association between the type of healthcare center (i.e., public or private) and responsiveness (p‑value = 0.896). However, there was a significant difference between gender (p‑value = 0.036) and education level (p‑value = 0.014) with responsiveness. According to the respondents, prompt attention and choice were the most and least important dimensions, respectively. Conclusions: Evaluation of HSR in the era of COVID‑19 not only provides a tool for qualitative assessment of services but also plays an important role in providing feedback to policymakers to adopt effective policies.

Keywords


Covid‑19; healthcare delivery; health system responsiveness; Iran

Full Text:

PDF

References


Huang C, Wang Y, Li X, Ren L, Zhao J, Hu Y, et al. Clinical

features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in

Wuhan, China. Lancet 2020;395:497‑506.

Lahariya C. Send a ‘good camel’ to the tent: Health system

responsiveness to advance universal health coverage. J Postgrad

Med 2020;66:125‑7.

Mirzoev T, Kane S. What is health systems responsiveness?

Review of existing knowledge and proposed conceptual

framework. BMJ Global Health 2017;2:e000486.

Valentine NB, de Silva A, Kawabata K, Darby C, Murray CJ,

Evans DB. Health system responsiveness: Concepts, domains

and operationalization. Health Systems Performance Assessment:

Debates, Methods and Empiricism. Geneva: World Health

Organization; 2003. p. 96.

Bramesfeld A, Klippel U, Seidel G, Schwartz FW, Dierks M‑L.

How do patients expect the mental health service system to act? Testing the WHO responsiveness concept for its appropriateness

in mental health care. Soc Sci Med 2007;65:880‑9.

Valentine N, Prasad A, Rice N, Robone S, Chatterji S. Health

systems responsiveness: A measure of the acceptability of

health‑care processes and systems from the user’s perspective.

Performance Measurement for Health System Improvement

Chicago, Hospital Research and Educational Trust. 2009. p. 138‑86.

Jones AM, Rice N, Robone S, Dias PR. Inequality and

polarisation in health systems’ responsiveness: A cross‑country

analysis. J Health Econ 2011;30:616‑25.

Arab M, Rahimi‑Foroushani A, Akbari Sari A, Khammarnia M,

Sadeghi A, Siavashi E. Comparison of responsiveness rate

among private and social security hospitals in Tehran city. J

Hosp 2015;14:29‑39.

Röttger J, Blümel M, Köppen J, Busse R. Forgone care

among chronically ill patients in Germany‑Results from a

cross‑sectional survey with 15,565 individuals. Health Policy

;120:170‑8.

Valentine N, Verdes‑Tennant E, Bonsel G. Health systems’

responsiveness and reporting behaviour: Multilevel analysis of

the influence of individual‑level factors in 64 countries. Soc Sci

Med 2015;138:152‑60.

Abdoli A. Iran, sanctions, and the COVID‑19 crisis. J Med Econ

;23:1461‑5.

Murphy A, Abdi Z, Harirchi I, McKee M, Ahmadnezhad E.

Economic sanctions and Iran’s capacity to respond to COVID‑19.

Lancet Public Health 2020;5:e254.

Groenewegen PP, Kerssens JJ, Sixma HJ, van der Eijk I,

Boerma WG. What is important in evaluating health care

quality? An international comparison of user views. BMC Health

Serv Res 2005;5:16.

Qin L, Chen S, Feng X, Luo B, Chen Y. Patient‑perceived health

system responsiveness of the epilepsy management project in

Rural China during the period of COVID‑19. Healthcare (Basel)

;10:799.

Karami-Tanha F, Moradi-Lakeh M, Fallah-Abadi H, Nojomi

M. Health system responsiveness for care of patients with heart

failure: evidence form a university hospital. Archives of Iranian

medicine. 2014;17:736-40.

Ebrahimipour H, Najjar AV, Jahani AK, Pourtaleb A, Javadi M,

Rezazadeh A, et al. Health system responsiveness: a case study

of general hospitals in Iran. International journal of health policy

and management. 2013;1:85.

Karami-Tanha F, Moradi-Lakeh M, Fallah-Abadi H, Nojomi M.

Health system responsiveness for care of patients with heart

failure: evidence form a university hospital. Archives of Iranian

medicine. 2014;17.

Organization WH. The world health report 2000: health systems:

improving performance: World Health Organization; 2000.

Forouzan AS. Assessing responsiveness in the mental health care

system: the case of Tehran: Umeå universitet; 2015.

Bramesfeld A, Wedegärtner F, Elgeti H, Bisson S. How

does mental health care perform in respect to service users'

expectations? Evaluating inpatient and outpatient care in

Germany with the WHO responsiveness concept. BMC Health

Services Research. 2007;7:1.

Forouzan S, Padyab M, Rafiey H, Ghazinour M, Dejman M,

San Sebastian MJFiph. Measuring the mental health-care system

responsiveness: results of an outpatient survey in Tehran.

;3:285.

Alavi M, Khodaie Ardakani MR, Moradi-Lakeh M,

Sajjadi H, Shati M, Noroozi M, et al. Responsiveness of Physical

Rehabilitation Centers in Capital of Iran: Disparities and Related

Determinants in Public and Private Sectors. 2018;6:317.

Sajjadi F, Moradi-Lakeh M, Nojomi M, Baradaran HR, Azizi F.

Health system responsiveness for outpatient care in people with

diabetes Mellitus in Tehran. Medical journal of the Islamic

Republic of Iran. 2015;29:293.

Karami-Tanha F, Fallah-Abadi H. Health system responsiveness

for care of patients with heart failure: evidence form a university

hospital. Archives of Iranian medicine. 2014;17:736.

Peltzer K, Phaswana-Mafuya N. Patient experiences and health

system responsiveness among older adults in South Africa.

Global health action. 2012;5.

Mohammadi A, K K. Patients' Perspectives on Responsiveness in

Outpatient Clinics of Hospitals at Zanjan University of Medical

Sciences. . PCNM. 2015;5:80-92.

Ebrahimipour H, Vafaei Najjar A, Khanijahani A, Pourtaleb A,

Javadi M, Rezazadeh A, et al. Health system responsiveness: a

case study of general hospitals in Iran. International journal of

health policy and management. 2013;1:99-105.

Piroozi B, Mohammadi Bolban Abad A, GH M. Assessing

Health System Responsiveness after the implementation of

Health System reform: A case study of Sanandaj, 2014-2015.

Iranian Journal of Epidemiology. 2016;11:1-9.

Valentine N, Darby C, Bonsel GJ. Which aspects of non-clinical

quality of care are most important? Results from WHO's general

population surveys of “health systems responsiveness” in 41

countries. Social science & medicine. 2008;66:1939-50.

Kowal P, Naidoo N, Williams SR, Chatterji S. Performance of the

health system in China and Asia as measured by responsiveness.

Health. 2011;3:638.