Application of “Human Factor Analysis and Classification System” (HFACS) Model to the Prevention of Medical Errors and Adverse Events: A Systematic Review

Mahdi Jalali, Habibollah Dehghan, Ehsanollah Habibi, Nima Khakzad

Abstract


Hospitals, as one of most important subsectors in human societies, are responsible for providing safe and effective medical services to clients. But sometimes these hospitals are the source of injury and death in patients by creating medical errors. In this systematic review study, the application of human factor analysis and classification system (HFACS) method in the classification of medical errors was investigated. Major electronic databases including Scopus, Web of Science, and MEDLINE were searched. All studies that investigated the application of HFACS method for coding, causation, and classification of medical errors and adverse events conducted from 2001 until February 2021 were included. A total of 108 articles were found. Due to duplication, 18 studies were removed from the review list. After reading the titles and abstracts, 50 of these publications were excluded because they had objectives different from this review. The remaining 40 publications were retrieved for further assessment. Of these, 28 publications were excluded because it did not meet the inclusion criteria. Finally, 12 articles remained for the final systematic review. We found that in 65% of the selected studies, preconditions for unsafe acts have been the major causal level of medical errors and adverse events. In the majority of the studies, communication and coordination, adverse mental states, physical environment, crew resource management, and technological environment have also been recognized as the most important causal categories in this study. As a result, to prevent medical errors and adverse events, the main focus should be on controlling the preconditions for unsafe acts including personnel factors, operator conditions, and environmental factors.

International Journal of Preventive Medicine 14():127, November 2023. | DOI: 10.4103/ijpvm.ijpvm_123_22

 

Corresponding Author: Dr. Habibollah Dehghan

E‑mail: ha_dehghan@hlth.mui.ac.ir

You can also search for this author in: PubMed  Google Scholar


Keywords


Adverse event; health care system; human factor analysis and classification system; medical error; patient safety

Full Text:

PDF

References


Cohen TN. A Human Factors Approach for Identifying Latent

Failures in Healthcare Settings [Doctor of Philosophy]. Daytona

Beach, Florida: Embry‑Riddle Aeronautical University; 2017.

Garrouste‑Orgeas M, Philippart F, Bruel C, Max A, Lau N,

Misset B. Overview of medical errors and adverse events. Ann

Intensive Care 2012;2:1‑9.

Vincent C. Patient Safety. 2nd ed. Hoboken‑USA: John Wiley &

Sons; 2011.

World Health Organization. Patient Safety: Making Health Care

Safer (No. WHO/HIS/SDS/2017.11). Geneva; Licence: CC

BY‑NC‑SA 3.0 IGO: World Health Organization; 2017.

Manias E, Kusljic S, Wu A. Interventions to reduce medication

errors in adult medical and surgical settings: A systematic

review. Ther Adv Drug Saf 2020;11:2042098620968309. doi:

1177/2042098620968309.

Sutherland A, Canobbio M, Clarke J, Randall M, Skelland T,

Weston E. Incidence and prevalence of intravenous medication

errors in the UK: A systematic review. Eur J Hosp Pharm

;27:3‑8.

Ahmed AH, Giri J, Kashyap R, Singh B, Dong Y, Kilickaya O,

et al. Outcome of adverse events and medical errors in the

intensive care unit: A systematic review and meta‑analysis. Am J

Med Qual 2015;30:23‑30.

Diller T, Helmrich G, Dunning S, Cox S, Buchanan A,

Shappell S. The human factors analysis classification

system (HFACS) applied to health care. Am J Med Qual

;29:181‑90.

Burns LR. Systemic and human factors that contribute to medical

error: A study of higher reliability [Doctoral dissertation]. Faculty

of the College of Education, University of Houston; 2017.

Shappell SA, Wiegmann DA. Applying reason: The human

factors analysis and classification system (HFACS). Hum Factors

Aerosp Saf 2001;1:59‑86.

Wiegmann DA, Shappell SA. A human error approach to aviation

accident analysis: The human factors analysis and classification

system. Coll Aviat Rev 2016;34:102.

Reason J. Human Error. New York: Cambridge University Press;

Fukuoka K, Furusho M. Relationship between latent conditions

and the characteristics of holes in marine accidents based on the

Swiss cheese model. WMU J Marit Affairs 2016;15:267‑92.

Reason J, Hollnagel E, Paries J. Revisiting the Swiss cheese

model of accidents. J Clin Eng 2006;27:110‑5.

Kamoun F, Nicho M. Human and organizational factors of

healthcare data breaches: The Swiss cheese model of data

breach causation and prevention. Int J Healthc Inf Syst Inform

;9:42‑60.

Hickey J, Van Eikema Hommes Q. Effectiveness of accident

models: System theoretic model vs. the Swiss Cheese model:

A case study of a US Coast Guard aviation mishap. Int J Risk

Assess Manag 2013;17:46‑68.

Dash AK, Bhattacharjee RM, Paul PS. Gap analysis of accident

investigation methodology in the Indian mining industry‑an

application of Swiss cheese model and 5‑why model. IAMURE

Int J Ecol Conserv 2015;15:1-27.

Chen S‑T, Wall A, Davies P, Yang Z, Wang J, Chou Y‑H.

A Human and Organisational Factors (HOFs) analysis

method for marine casualties using HFACS‑Maritime

Accidents (HFACS‑MA). Saf Sci 2013;60:105‑14.

Daramola AY. An investigation of air accidents in Nigeria using

the human factors analysis and classification system (HFACS)

framework. J Air Transp Manag 2014;35:39‑50.

Kilic B, Gümüş E. Application of HFACS to the nighttime

aviation accidents and incidents. J Aviat 2020;4:10‑6.

Kilic B, Gundogdu S. Human factors in air cargo operations: An

analysis using HFACS. J Aviat Res 2020;2:101‑14.

Li C, Tang T, Chatzimichailidou MM, Jun GT, Waterson P.

A hybrid human and organisational analysis method for railway

accidents based on STAMP‑HFACS and human information

processing. Appl Ergon 2019;79:122‑42.

Patterson JM, Shappell SA. Operator error and system deficiencies:

Analysis of 508 mining incidents and accidents from Queensland,

Australia using HFACS. Accid Anal Prev 2010;42:1379‑85.

Small A. Human factors analysis and classification

system (HFACS): As applied to Asiana Airlines Flight 214.

J Purdue Undergrad Res 2020;10:18.

Uğurlu Ö, Yıldız S, Loughney S, Wang J. Modified human

factor analysis and classification system for passenger vessel accidents (HFACS‑PV). Ocean Eng 2018;161:47‑61.

Zhan Q, Zheng W, Zhao B. A hybrid human and organizational

analysis method for railway accidents based on HFACS‑Railway

Accidents (HFACS‑RAs). Saf Sci 2017;91:232‑50.

Judy GD, Lindsay DP, Gu D, Mullins BT, Mosaly PR,

Marks LB, et al. Incorporating human factors analysis and

classification system (HFACS) into analysis of reported near

misses and incidents in radiation oncology. Pract Radiat Oncol

;10:e312‑21.

Cohen TN, Wiegmann DA, Reeves ST, Boquet AJ, Shappell SA.

Coding human factors observations in surgery. Am J Med Qual

;32:556‑62.

Cohen TN, Francis SE, Wiegmann DA, Shappell SA,

Gewertz BL. Using HFACS‑healthcare to identify systemic

vulnerabilities during surgery. Am J Med Qual 2018;33:614‑22.

ElBardissi AW, Wiegmann DA, Dearani JA, Daly RC, Sundt TM 3rd.

Application of the human factors analysis and classification system

methodology to the cardiovascular surgery operating room. Ann

Thorac Surg 2007;83:1412‑8; discussion 1418‑9.

Souders CP, Dallas K, Kanji F, Cohen K, Eilber KS, Cohen T,

et al. Gender differences in perioperative patient safety reporting

systems at a tertiary medical center. J Urol 2020;203(Suppl

:e1256.

Thiels CA, Lal TM, Nienow JM, Pasupathy KS, Blocker RC,

Aho JM, et al. Surgical never events and contributing human

factors. Surgery 2015;158:515‑21.

Neuhaus C, Huck M, Hofmann G, St Pierre M, Weigand MA,

Lichtenstern C. Applying the human factors analysis

and classification system to critical incident reports in

anaesthesiology. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2018;62:1403‑11.

Hsieh MC, Chiang PY, Wang EMY, Kung WC, Hu YT, Huang

MS, et al. The investigation of human error analysis in adverse

drug events in Taiwan—From the perspective of causality

assessment. Hum Factors Ergon Manuf 2019;29:340-9.

Wiegmann DA, Shappell SA. A human error approach to aviation

accident analysis: The human factors analysis and classification

system. Coll Aviat Rev 2016;34:102.

Hsieh MC, Chiang PY, Wang EMY, Kung WC, Hu YT,

Huang MS, et al. The investigation of human error analysis

in adverse drug events in Taiwan—From the perspective of

causality assessment. Hum Factors Ergon Manuf 2019;29:340-9

Cohen TN, Cabrera JS, Litzinger TL, Captain KA, Fabian MA,

Miles SG, et al. Proactive safety management in trauma care:

Applying the human factors analysis and classification system.

J Healthc Qual 2018;40:89‑96.

Sadeghi M, Nekoie Z, Sheybani‑Tehrani D, Rejaliyan F,

Ferdowsi M. Root cause analysis of accidents with human

factors analysis and classification system (HFACS) using in

Imam Khomeini Hospital in Felavarjan, Isfahan, 2014. J Mil

Med 2017;19:351‑7.

Wiegmann DA, ElBardissi AW, Dearani JA, Daly RC, Sundt TM III.

Disruptions in surgical flow and their relationship to surgical errors:

An exploratory investigation. Surgery 2007;142:658‑65.

Xiao Y, Jones A, Zhang BB, Bennett M, Mears SC, Mabrey JD,

et al. Team consistency and occurrences of prolonged operative

time, prolonged hospital stay, and hospital readmission:

A retrospective analysis. World J Surg 2015;39:890‑6.

Mallett R, Conroy M, Saslaw LZ, Moffatt‑Bruce S. Preventing

wrong site, procedure, and patient events using a common cause

analysis. Am J Med Qual 2012;27:21‑9.

Awad SS, Fagan SP, Bellows C, Albo D, Green‑Rashad B,

De La Garza M, et al. Bridging the communication gap in

the operating room with medical team training. Am J Surg

;190:770‑4.

Bleakley A, Boyden J, Hobbs A, Walsh L, Allard J. Improving

teamwork climate in operating theatres: The shift from

multiprofessionalismto interprofessionalism. J Interprof Care

;20:461‑70.

Cima RR, Kollengode A, Storsveen AS, Weisbrod CA,

Deschamps C, Koch MB, et al. A multidisciplinary team

approach to retained foreign objects. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf

;35:123‑32.

Lingard L, Whyte S, Espin S, Ross Baker G, Orser B, Doran D.

Towards safer interprofessional communication: Constructing a

model of “utility” from preoperative team briefings. J Interprof

Care 2006;20:471‑83.

Brady AM, Malone AM, Fleming S. A literature review of the

individual and systems factors that contribute to medication

errors in nursing practice. J Nurs Manag 2009;17:679‑97.