?
IJPVM Int J Prev Med International Journal of Preventive Medicine International Journal of Preventive Medicine 2008-7802 2008-8213 Medknow Publications Pvt Ltd India IJPVM-5-217 Original Article Seeking comfort: Women mental health process in I. R. Iran: A grounded theory study Mohammadi Farahnaz Eftekhari Monir B Dejman Masoumeh Forouzan Ameneh S Mirabzadeh Arash Social Determinant of Health Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran Social Determinant of Health Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran Social Determinant of Health Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran Social Determinant of Health Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran Social Determinant of Health Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran Address for correspondence:Monir Eftekhari, Opposite AvestaPark, Undersecretary for Research and Technology, Tehran, Iran, Social Determinant of Health Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran eftekharimonir@yahoo.com February 2014 5 2 217 223 12 12 2012 Copyright: © International Journal of Preventive Medicine 2014

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Background:

Psychosocial factor is considered as intermediate social determinant of health, because it has powerful effects on health especially in women. Hence deeper understanding of the mental-health process needed for its promotion. The aim of this study was to explore women′s experience of the mental-health problem and related action-interactions activities to design the appropriate interventions.

Methods:

In-depth interviews with women 18-65 years were analyzed according to the grounded theory method. The selection of Participants was based on purposeful and theoretical sampling.

Results:

In this study, a substantive theory was generated; explaining how female with the mental-health problem handled their main concern, which was identified as their effort to achieve comfort (core variable). The other six categories are elements in this process. Daily stress as a trigger, satisfaction is the end point, marriage is the key point and action - interaction activities in this process are strengthening human essence, Developing life skills and help seeking.

Conclusions:

Better understanding the mental-health process might be useful to design the interventional program among women with mental-health problems.

Daily stress grounded theory Iran mental-health promotion women
</sec> <sec> <title>Background

In 2005, commission on the social determinants of health, as a global network brought together by the World Health Organization (WHO) to give support in tackling the social causes of health inequities. 1 According to the conceptual framework of Social determinant of health, psychosocial factor, and behaviors are considered as intermediate social determinant of health because; they have powerful effects on health. Psychological circumstances can cause long-term stress, anxiety, insecurity, low self-esteem, social isolation and lack of control over work, and home life specially in women. 2 Hence, it is needed to design and implement the interventional program to the mental-health promotion.

Many studies related to mental health promotion have been conducted in around the world. In 2006, Wright and Jorm verified the beliefs of young people and their parents about the effectiveness of interventions for mental disorders in Melbourne. The findings of this study suggested ways in which interventions can be labeled to make them more acceptable to these groups. 3

In 2007, Barry and Jenkins discussed that there are several key factors that influence the effectiveness of community collaborative partnerships in the mental-health promotion. 4

In 2009, in Iran, Ebadifard et al., conducted the Quasi-experimental study. The results of this project showed that the educational intervention through Belief, Attitude, Subjective Norm, and Enabling Factors (BASNEF) model was affected on attitude and healthy behaviors in girl adolescent. 5

Also, in Iran, in 2010, a community based participatory research was designed by Dr. Malek Afzali. In this study, at first, the elderly health needs assessment was carried out and then based on community participation, the interventional programs have been designed. The results showed that these programs were affective to promote healthy life-style in this age group. 6

Despite various studies regarding mental-health and community based participatory research, as far as we know very few studies have explored narratives of the mental-health process and ways to promote it by this approach. One way to improve this situation would be to explore this process and concern to participant′s recommendations with experience from individuals. For this reason, the aim of this study was to explore women′s experience of the mental-health problem and related action-interactions activities to design the appropriate interventions.

Methods

In this study, we use Grounded theory as a qualitative method that is useful to generate new understanding about the processes 7 that interact to form mental-health in women. In this method, the meaning is constructed and developed via social interactions. 8 , 9 Data collection started in December 2011 and ended in July 2012.

Participants and procedure

In-depth interviews were conducted with sixteen married women 18-65 years, who are residents in Western part of Tehran (Olympic area). 10 The reason of selection this age group was based on the epidemiology of mental-health problems in women that related to reproductive transition and also there is a significant difference among this age group with adolescence (less than 18 year old) and elderly (more than 65 year old). 11 The number of participants was determined according to data saturation, 12 it means that, there is no new idea and experiences about subject. 13 At first, based on purposeful sampling, with the aim of maximal variation of the participants′ experiences, the interviews were implemented. Variations were initially chosen regarding ages, education, number of children, status of employment. 9 However, the following participants were then chosen based on theoretical sampling to provide depth and different dimensions for rich categories.

Theoretical sampling was used in two ways: First, as the interviews proceeded and new questions arose in order to more exploration. Second, in some cases, there were participants that might affect the processes studied. Therefore, we framed the theoretical sample to include two single women and two married men 14 and finally the total number of participants in this study was twenty based on data saturation. In each interview, the moderator began the interview by explaining the purpose of the study. Permission to audiotape the interview session was sought orally prior to the interviews. The discussion started with how the mental health might be defined and described. Then respondent was asked to define a day with the mental health problem. During the interview the appropriate probes with words as where, when, how and why were carried out. Probes were used to confirm concepts mentioned and to explore new areas. Each interview lasted almost 1-1.5 h and it has been ended when no new issues seemed to arise. The place of the interview was chosen based on the interviewee.

Analysis of data

Collection and analysis of data was carried out manually, it means that each interview was coded as soon as it was implemented. 15 The base of grounded theory analyses is looking for psychosocial processes 16 that first the raw data were fractured to initial codes and then these codes rebuilt the categories. Finally, the categories were integrated into an explanatory theory. Constant comparison, repetitive questioning and memo-writing are three main analytical tools were used during this entire process of analysis. 15 The steps of analysis consist of open coding, axial coding, and selective coding. 8

In the open coding process, the interview transcripts were broken down and conceptualized. 17 Furthermore, during this step, there was a continuous comparison for similarities and differences in different parts of the data that formed categories and subcategories. In axial coding, the category was seated on the center of the process as axis and related subcategories were situated around it. For better understanding of social process, the dimensions of categories were explored. In final step, in order to find pattern, we paid attention to social action - interactions. 18 In this phase, core category was recognized and explained the narratives of women with mental-health problems and their process of dealing with them. The analysis ended when the categories seemed to relate with each other and can explain the mental-health process. 19

In this study, different aspects of trustworthiness have been observed. Transferability, dependability and peer checking were performed throughout the analysis process.

Ethical aspects

In this study, ethical issues were considered. Informed consent was obtained from all the participants. They were assured that the data would be managed in line with regulations in the law of secrecy and anonymity. The local Ethics Committee of Welfare and Social Science University approved the study design.

Results

The demographic characteristics of participants are shown in Table 1.{Table 1}

In the analysis, a substantive theory was generated; explaining how female with daily stress handled their main concern which was identified as their effort to achieve comfort (Core variable). Six categories are integrated to initiate and subsequently to support and maintain core category that is presented according in following themes:

Daily stress as a trigger

According to participants view, daily stress has broad dimension from simple physiologic pain to major disability. The types of stress are classified to individual, familial and social stress:

a. Individual stress consists of physical disability and behavioral problem such as jealousy, lies and anger.

"…When the body and mind are healthy it means that the person has Mental health. Physical health effects on thinking…"

"…In my opinion, jealousy makes impaired mental health and I think, these people have busy mind and constantly comparison…"

b. Familial stress has different types such as Family dispute, leave home by parents, death of parents and lack of family support and so on.

"…With my father′s death, all of life′s responsibilities fell on my shoulders. Brothers did not work, I would feel responsible..."

c. Social stress: These problems have broad dimension such as economic, environmental and cultural problems. Poverty, Unemployment, job insecurity are in economic type, addiction, divorce and so on in social, traffic and air pollution in environmental and ethnic differences and some traditions in cultural problems have been presented.

"…We lived alone; we had a lot of economic problems...". "…Social problems are very important such as daily routines, traffic, and air pollution causes you to be worried about something…"

Strengthening human essence

In our study, all of positive and good human characteristic is named human essence. According to heavenly teaching, all of the people have been created based on clear essence that should be strengthened in different ways as follow:

· Strengthening the religious aspects:

The majority of participants mentioned that religion has good effect on mental-health. Some of them believed that prayer, Quran reading and participation in a religious meeting are helpful mechanisms in dealing with daily stress.

". ..In bad situation, the religion is very helpful, because it makes you feel not alone…"

"…Mentally healthy person who does not get angry easily and fast, it has control over his or her behavior, do not feel narcissism…"

0· Improvement of rational and positive thinking:

This means that the person in dealing with daily stress sees the glass half full and has logical thinking for problem solving.

"…We should learn that look at the problem without glasses…"

Improvement social relationship: One of the most important ways for strengthening human essence is having good social relationship and flexibility.

"….In my opinion, flexibility is a skill that helps us to keep calm …."

· Knowledge development:

Academic education and spending training courses are useful in health literacy promotion. Reading different books and magazines and participation in different courses can lead to develop mental-health knowledge.

Developing life skills

Based on participants view, study book is not enough for stress management, learning different life skills such as a coping mechanism, problem solving, and anger control are necessary for proper dealing daily stress. Moreover, improved performance such as future planning and priority setting are other steps for mental-health promotion. Monotony avoidance will be carried out by entertainment providing, recreation, traveling, listening to music, doing proper exercise, and finally female employment.

"…I know that the control aggression is good, but I don′t know how?"

Marriage is a key point for women

For Iranian women, marriage is a key point. Because it is the first right experience to be with the opposite sex. According to Islamic teaching, all of people need to marry and have a family. Good choose of spouse and marital adjustment is very important for women′s mental-health. Need to emotional support, economic dependency, and rely on male power are as reasons for special pay attention to marriage.

Help seeking

Help seeking consist of three parts:

A. Take the consultation:

Based on the participant′s view, the consultation resources consist of experts, family member, friends, and some teachers. The best source of counseling, based on most participants′ opinion was experts. However, there are some barriers such as cost and social stigma.

"Each person tends to visit secretly by psychologist, because when people know, they think a person has a mental problem."

Some participants prefer to consult with family members specially parents and spouse.

"I′d rather talk to my family because I believe that they know better what is best for me and they have more experience."

In the lower age group, people like to talk with their peers due to mutual understanding and in women with academic education, university teachers are an important source for consulting.

B. Resource Finding:

This item divided to:

a.

Information resource such as books, magazines, websites, and seminar and

b.

Emotional resource consist of familial support, spouse support and peers support as follow:

Familial support

Based on participants view, familial support has various types in different life steps such as childhood, adolescence, youth and adulthood periods. In childhood phase, they have devoted their lives to educating the children. Emotional support of mother and secure protection of father cause to train human essence. Furthermore, pay attention of parents to children′s problems are very important to make personality in future.

"I feel, I have a permanent protection that defense from me"

"Emotional support is very important. I had the support of my mother and I relied on her before marriage"

Another support of family members is their role to choose appropriate spouse. According to the majority of participants view, this role is very important in women mental-health.

"When I want to marry, my father said to me, not to endure excess. The door of this house opens always for you."

Furthermore, after marriage, the family support continues and the new couple need to material and spiritual support of parents.

"In my opinion, material and spiritual supports of our families are very important in our life. Consulting with them is very effective in correct decisions."

Spouse support

Based on the majority of participants view, appropriate and good marriage is very effective in women′s mental-health. Suitable choose and having healthy spouse from mentally aspect is necessary for perfection. Mutual trust can cause emotional relationship between the couple and this provides more kindness in family. In contrast, unhealthy mate ruin logical relations in the family. Some participants believed that economic dependency on husband is important. But a few of them also paid attention to women independency. Really, women′s emotion plus men′s power equal to happiness and satisfaction in life.

"…when he understand and help me, I enjoy life..."

"….unhealthy husband destroys heart and soil …."

Peers support

Some of participants specially youth believed that friends support is more important than family due to mutual understanding. Seeking this resource is completely voluntarily.

"When you are sad, you need ear not mouth. In this situation, friends are ears..."

Using non-medical therapy

Using herbal medicine such as borage in some cases is useful. Some participant said that these drugs have no side-effects. Furthermore, some exercise movement can help strengthening the skill of stress management.

Satisfaction as the end point

All of The participants with seeking tranquility in the mental-health process try to achieve satisfaction. In participants view, satisfied persons are mentally healthy persons. Spiritual dimension of satisfaction is more important than others.

"…In my opinion, mentally healthy person, who is a person that has a piece of mind and satisfied from her life..."

Discussion

The core category generated, seeking comfort, explains how women to deal with daily stress and with which mechanisms reach to feel calm. Our participants managed to transform emotional and cognitive experience of living with stress to understand the mental-health process.

The categories that emerged provided the study paradigm of women mental-health Figure 1.

The grounded theory of women mental health

Figure 1

In this paradigm, casual pathway is daily stress that begins the process. And it is the same definition of mental-health in WHO, "be able to cope with the normal stresses of life." 20

Action - interactions extracted in this study, consist of some components such as strengthening human essence, developing life skills and help seeking. All of these actions have been implemented to cope with stress. Based on Quran teaching, dealing with psychological stress will be carried out through referring to human essence. 21 Many studies present the role of religious belief in the mental-health promotion. 22

In this study, results show that academic education and spending training courses are useful in health literacy promotion. Furthermore, other studies emphasized that modern education increased knowledge about surroundings, events, and health issue and people know how to better handle personal issues and concerns. 23 Developing life skills such as problem solving and anger management via participation in training workshops is one of the interactions for dealing daily stress. Some studies show that these interventions are effective in the mental-health promotion in different age groups. 24 Help seeking is another component of paradigm. The data also reflect the importance of receiving positive support specially spouse support in coping with daily stress. Participants emphasized that marital adjustment is a key point for women. Factors related to include choice of spouse, age of marriage, male-female roles, and conflict resolution. 25

Seeking support from others such as experts, family members, peers and community is essential for women. Take consultation from experts is more useful than others, but there are some barriers such as social stigma, cost and accessibility. In 1998, Crocker and Jennifer considered the social and psychological experience of stigma from the perspective of both the stigmatizer and the stigmatized individual. The results showed that the social stigma is an important barrier in help seeking in mental-health problems. 26 It seems that, there are a lot of action interactions for promoting mental-health. The study of Cloninger in USA described that mental-health and its disorders are emergent properties of complex interactions among multidimensional neuroadaptive systems. 27

Limitations

The present study, illustrates the participant′s experiences in 20 in depth interviews and should for methodological reasons (qualitative approach) not be generalized to other conditions. Furthermore, lack of participation of representatives from women Non Governmental Organizations (NGOS) in interviews was another limitation in this study.

In this paradigm, there is intervening factors that consist of individual, familial, and social factors that the negative aspects of them are mentioned in daily stress part as barratries. The positive aspect of these factors is facilitating for mental-health promotion. Finally, the entire activities in this process for achieving the satisfactions. Based on results, our suggestion for effective interventions in seeking comfort process is learning ways to deal with stress. And, our following planning in this study, an assessment the ways of coping in women and designing the training package for developing appropriate coping mechanisms.

Conclusions

Better understanding the mental-health process might be useful to design the interventional program among women with mental-health problems.

Krech R Healthy public policies: Looking ahead Health Promot Int 2011 26 Suppl 2 ii268 72 Raphael D Escaping from the Phantom Zone: Social determinants of health, public health units and public policy in Canada Health Promot Int 2009 24 193 8 Jorm AF Wright A Beliefs of young people and their parents about the effectiveness of interventions for mental disorders Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2007 41 656 66 Barry MM Jenkins R.Implementing Mental Health Promotion Philadelphia, USA: Churchill Livingstone; 7 Jenkins R Implementing Mental Health Promotion Philadelphia, USA: Churchill Livingstone; 2007 Ebadifard AF Solhi M Roudbari M Sadeghi A Survey the effect of educational intervention through the BASNEF model on preventive behaviors according to mental health in girl adolescents J Guilan University Med Sci 2010 73:20 29 Malekafzali H Baradaran Eftekhari M Hejazi F Khojasteh T Noot RH Falahat K The effectiveness of educational intervention in the health promotion in elderly people Iran J Public Health 2010 39 18 23 Mills J Bonner A Francis K The development of constructivist grounded theory Int J Qual Methods 2008 5 25 35 Strauss A Corbin J Basics of Qualitative Research Thousand Oaks; SAGE: London; 8 Basics of Qualitative Research Thousand Oaks; SAGE: London; 1998 Komives SR Owen E J Longerbeam SD Mainella FC Osteen L Developing a leadership identity: A grounded theory J Coll Stud Dev 2005 46 593 611 Legard R Keegan J Ward K In-depth interviews.Qualitative Research Practice: A Guide for Social Science Students and Researchers SAGE: London 3 In-depth interviews Qualitative Research Practice: A Guide for Social Science Students and Researchers SAGE: London 2003 p 138-69 Blehar MC Public health context of women′s mental health research Psychiatr Clin North Am 2003 26 781 99 Bowen GA Naturalistic inquiry and the saturation concept: A research note Qual Res 2008 8 137 52 Sandelowski M Sample size in qualitative research Res Nurs Health 1995 18 179 83 Charmaz K Constructing Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide Through Qualitative Analysis New Jersey: SAGE (London); 6 Constructing Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide Through Qualitative Analysis New Jersey: SAGE (London); 2006 Glaser BG Strauss AL The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research New Jersey: Aldine de Gruyter; 7 The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research New Jersey: Aldine de Gruyter; 1967 Stern PN Grounded theory methodology: Its uses and processes Image (IN) 1980 12 20 3 Hallberg LR The core category of grounded theory: Making constant comparisons Int J Qual Stud Health Well-being 2006 1 141 8 Charmaz K Qualitative interviewing and grounded theory analysis London: Sage Publication; 2 Qualitative interviewing and grounded theory analysis London: Sage Publication; 2002 Morse JM Barrett M Mayan M Olson K Spiers J Verification strategies for establishing reliability and validity in qualitative research Int J Qual Methods 2008 1 13 22 Health W H.O D H O D o M and S Abuse Mental Health Atlas World Health Organization; 2005 Moazedi K Asadi A Mental health status in the quran J Ardabil Univ Med Sci 2012 12 85 96 Sadeghi MR Bagherzadeh Ladari, Haghshenas M.A study of religious attitude and mental health in students of Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences J Mazandaran Univ Med Sci 2010 20 71 5 Knowles MS The Modern Practice of Adult Education New York: Association Press; 0 The Modern Practice of Adult Education New York: Association Press; 1970 Coon DW Thompson L Steffen A Sorocco K Gallagher-Thompson D Anger and depression management: Psychoeducational skill training interventions for women caregivers of a relative with dementia Gerontologist 2003 43 678 89 De Vaus DA Marriage and mental health Familly matters 2002 (62) P: 26 32 Major B O′Brien LT The social psychology of stigma Annu Rev Psychol 2005 56 393 421 Cloninger CR A new conceptual paradigm from genetics and psychobiology for the science of mental health Aust N Z J Psychiatry 1999 33 174 86