Non‑Pharmacological Infection Prevention and Control Interventions in COVID‑19: What Does the Current Evidence Say?

P. Ravi Shankar, Subish Palaian, Venkataramana Vannal, Chandrashekhar T. Sreeramareddy

Abstract


Coronavirus disease‑19 (COVID‑19), a major global public health emergency has significantly impacted human health and livelihoods. The pandemic continues to spread and treatments and vaccines are at different stages of development. Mass vaccination has been rolled out worldwide. This review article provides a narrative summary of the evidence on various non‑pharmacological interventions (NPIs) for COVID‑19 containment. The authors reviewed the evidence published by the Norwegian Institute of Public Health map of COVID‑19 evidence. Additional literature was identified from PubMed and Google Scholar, preprint sites, and news media. The search terms included “Social distancing measures” and “COVID 19”, “Non‑pharmacological interventions’’ and “COVID 19”, “COVID‑19”, “non‑pharmacological interventions”, “face mask”, etc. The strength of the evidence for most studies on NPIs was ‘weak to moderate’ for restrictive NPIs. Ascertaining the impact of each NPI as a standalone intervention is difficult since NPIs are implemented simultaneously with other measures. Varying testing and reporting strategies across the countries and classification of deaths directly caused by COVID‑19 create challenges in assessing the impact of restrictive NPIs on the case numbers and deaths. Evidence on hygiene measures such as face mask is more robust in design providing credible evidence on prevention of COVID‑19 infection. Evidence from modeling studies, natural before‑after studies, and anecdotal evidence from the strategies adopted by ‘role model’ countries suggests that continued use of NPIs is the only containment strategy until ‘herd immunity’ is achieved to reduce the severe disease and mortality.

Keywords


COVID‑19; masks; pandemics; prevention and control

Full Text:

PDF

References


COVID‑19 dashboard by the Center for systems science and

engineering at Johns Hopkins University. Available from: https://

coronavirus.jhu.edu/map.html. [Last accessed on 2021 Dec 03].

Pak A, Adegboye OA, Adekunle AI, Rahman KM, McBryde ES,

Eisen DP. Economic Consequences of the COVID-19 Outbreak:

the Need for Epidemic Preparedness. Front Public Health.

;8:241.

Live map of COVID‑19 evidence. Available from: https://www.

fhi.no/en/qk/systematic‑reviews‑hta/map/. [Last accessed on

Mar 28].

Schünemann H, Brożek J, Guyatt G, Oxman A. Introduction

to GRADE Handbook. Handbook for grading the quality of

evidence and the strength of recommendations using the GRADE

approach. Updated October 2013. Available from: https://gdt.

gradepro.org/app/handbook/handbook.html. [Last accessed on

Mar 28].

Viner R, Russell S, Croker H, Packer J, Ward J, Stansfield C,

et al. School closure and management practices during coronavirus

outbreaks including COVID‑19: A rapid narrative systematic

review. Available from: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.

cfm?abstract_id=3556648. [Last accessed on 2021 Mar 28].

Koo JR, Cook AR, Park M, Sun Y, Sun H, Lim JT, et al.

Interventions to mitigate early spread of SARS‑CoV‑2 in

Singapore: A modelling study. Lancet Infect Dis 2020;20:678‑8.

Cowling BJ, Ali ST, Ng TWY, Tsang TK, Li JCM, Fong MW,

et al. Impact assessment of non‑pharmaceutical interventions

against coronavirus disease 2019 and influenza in Hong Kong:

An observational study. Lancet Public Health 2020;5:e279-88.

Ludvigsson JF. Systematic review of COVID‑19 in children

shows milder cases and a better prognosis than adults. Acta

Paediatr 2020;109:1088-95.

Imai N, Gaythorpe KAM, Abbott S, Bhatia S, van Elsland S,

Prem K, et al. Adoption and impact of non-pharmaceutical

interventions for COVID-19. Wellcome Open Res. 2020;5:59.

Becchetti L, Conzo G, Conzo P, Salustri F. Understanding the

heterogeneity of adverse COVID‑19 outcomes: The role of poor

quality of air and lockdown decisions. Available from: https://

ssrn.com/abstract=3572548.

Nussbaumer‑Streit B, Mayr V, Dobrescu AI, Chapman A,

Persad E, Klerings I, et al. Quarantine alone or in combination

with other public health measures to control COVID-19: A rapid

review. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2020;4:CD013574.

Lasry A, Kidder D, Hast M, Poovey J, Sunshine G, Winglee K,

et al. Timing of community mitigation and changes in reported

COVID‑19 and community mobility ― Four U.S. metropolitan

areas, February 26–April 1, 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly

Rep 2020;69:451–7.

Yang X, Xu T, Jia P, Xia H, Guo L, Zhang L, et al. Transportation,

germs, culture: A dynamic graph model of COVID‑19 outbreak.

Available from: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3544816. [Last

accessed on 2021 Mar 28].

Gu E, Li L. Crippled community governance and suppressed

scientific/professional communities: A critical assessment of

failed early warning for the COVID‑19 outbreak in China. J

Chinese Governance 2020;5:160‑77.

Lau H, Khosrawipour V, Kocbach P, Mikolajczyk A, Schubert J,

Bania J, et al. The positive impact of lockdown in Wuhan on

containing the COVID‑19 outbreak in China. J Travel Med

;27:taaa037.

Anzai A, Kobayashi T, Linton NM, Kinoshita R,

Hayashi K, Suzuki A, et al. Assessing the impact of reduced

travel on exportation dynamics of novel coronavirus

infection (COVID‑19). J Clin Med 2020;9:601.

Wells CR, Sah P, Moghadas SM, Pandey A, Shoukat A, Wang Y, et al. Impact of international travel and border control measures

on the global spread of the novel 2019 coronavirus outbreak.

Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2020;117:7504‑9.

Lau H, Khosrawipour V, Kocbach P, Mikolajczyk A, Ichii H,

Zacharski M, et al. The association between international and

domestic air traffic and the coronavirus (COVID‑19) outbreak.

J Microbiol Immunol Infect 2020;53:467‑72.

Petersen E, McCloskey B, Hui DS, Kock R, Ntoumi F,

Memish ZA, et al. COVID‑19 travel restrictions and the

International Health Regulations ‑ Call for an open debate on

easing of travel restrictions. Int J Infect Dis 2020;94:88‑90.

Yougov: Coronavirus: How do attitudes differ across

the world? Yougov.co.uk. 2020. Available from: https://

yougov.co.uk/topics/health/articles‑reports/2020/03/04/

coronavirus‑how‑do‑attitudes‑differ‑across‑world. [Last accessed

on 2021 Mar 28].

Zhu W, Li X, Wu Y, Xu C, Li L, Yang J, et al. Community

quarantine strategy against coronavirus disease 2019 in Anhui:

An evaluation based on trauma center patients. Int J Infect Dis

;96:417‑21.

Maier BF, Brockmann D. Effective containment explains

subexponential growth in recent confirmed COVID‑19 cases in

China. Science 2020;368:742-6.

Ng Y, Li Z, Chua YX, Chaw WL, Zhao Z, Er B, et al.

Evaluation of the effectiveness of surveillance and containment

measures for the first 100 patients with COVID‑19 in

Singapore ‑ January 2‑February 29, 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal

Wkly Rep 2020;69:307-11.

Webster RK, Brooks SK, Smith LE, Woodland L, Wessely S,

Rubin GJ. How to improve adherence with quarantine: Rapid

review of the evidence. Public Health 2020;182:163-9.

Bodas M, Peleg K. Self‑isolation compliance in the COVID‑19

era influenced by compensation: Findings from a recent survey

in Israel. Health Aff (Millwood) 2020;39:936‑41.

Brooks SK, Webster RK, Smith LE, Woodland L, Wessely S,

Greenberg N, et al. The psychological impact of quarantine

and how to reduce it: Rapid review of the evidence. Lancet

;395:912-20.

Bausch DG. Precision physical distancing for COVID‑19: An

important tool in unlocking the lockdown. Am J Trop Med Hyg

;103:22‑4.

Wee LE, Conceicao EP, Sim XYJ, Aung MK, Tan KY, Wong HM,

et al. Minimizing intra‑hospital transmission of COVID‑19: The

role of social distancing. J Hosp Infect 2020;105:113‑5.

Duczmal LH, Almeida ACL, Duczmal DB, Alves CRL,

Magalhães FCO, Lima MS, et al. Vertical social distancing

policy is ineffective to contain the COVID‑19 pandemic. Cad

Saude Publica 2020;36:e00084420.

Courtemanche C, Garuccio J, Le A, Pinkston J, Yelowitz A.

Strong social distancing measures in the United States

reduced the COVID‑19 growth rate. Health Aff (Millwood)

;39:1237‑46.

MacIntyre CR, Chughtai AA. A rapid systematic review of the

efficacy of face masks and respirators against coronaviruses

and other respiratory transmissible viruses for the community,

healthcare workers and sick patients. Int J Nurs Stud

;108:103629.

Douglas D, Douglas R. Addressing the corona virus pandemic:

Will a novel filtered eye mask help? Int J Infect Dis

;95:340-4.

Leung CC, Lam TH, Cheng KK. Mass masking in the COVID‑19

epidemic: People need guidance. Lancet 2020;395:945.

Ma QX, Shan H, Zhang HL, Li GM, Yang RM, Chen JM.

Potential utilities of mask‑wearing and instant hand hygiene for

fighting SARS‑CoV‑2. J Med Virol 2020;92:1567‑71.

Stern D, López‑Olmedo N, Pérez‑Ferrer C, González‑Morales R,

Canto‑Osorio F, Barrientos‑Gutiérrez T. Revisión rápida del uso

de cubrebocas quirúrgicos en ámbito comunitario e infecciones

respiratorias agudas [Rapid review of the use of community‑wide

surgical masks and acute respiratory infections]. Salud Publica

Mex 2020;62:319‑30.

Cheng VC, Wong SC, Chuang VW, So SY, Chen JH, Sridhar S,

et al. The role of community‑wide wearing of face mask for

control of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID‑19) epidemic due

to SARS‑CoV‑2. J Infect 2020;81:107‑14.

Eikenberry SE, Mancuso M, Iboi E, Phan T, Eikenberry K,

Kuang Y, et al. To mask or not to mask: Modeling the potential

for face mask use by the general public to curtail the COVID‑19

pandemic. Infect Dis Model 2020;5:293‑308.

Machida M, Nakamura I, Saito R, Nakaya T, Hanibuchi T,

Takamiya T, et al. Adoption of personal protective measures by

ordinary citizens during the COVID‑19 outbreak in Japan. Int J

Infect Dis 2020;94:139‑44.

Paludan‑Müller AS, Boesen K, Klerings I, Jørgensen KJ,

Munkholm K. Hand cleaning with ash for reducing the spread of

viral and bacterial infections: A rapid review. Cochrane Database

Syst Rev 2020;4:CD013597.

Cohen J. Underreporting of COVID‑19 coronavirus deaths in the

U.S. and Europe (Update). Available from: https://www.forbes.

com/sites/joshuacohen/2020/04/14/underreporting-of-covid-19deaths-in-the-us-and-europe/?sh=5abd496682d7. [Last accessed

on 2021 Mar 28].

Lacson: DOH may be underreporting local COVID‑19 cases.

Available from: https://news.abs‑cbn.com/news/03/07/20/

lacson‑doh‑may ‑be‑underreporting‑local‑covid‑ 19‑cases. [Last

accessed on 2021 Mar 28].

India could possibly be under reporting COVID cases:

K Sujatha Rao, former health secretary. Available

from: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/

p o l i t i c s ‑ a n d ‑ n a t i o n / i n d i a ‑ c o u l d ‑ p o s s i b l y ‑ b e ‑ u n d e r

‑reporting‑covid‑cases‑k‑sujatha‑rao‑former‑health‑secretary/

articleshow/74815001.cms. [Last accessed on 2021 Mar 28].

China underreporting thousands of COVID‑19 deaths.

Available from: https://www.njhomelandsecurity.gov/analysis/

china‑underreporting‑thousands‑of‑covid‑19‑deaths. [Last

accessed on 2021 Mar 28].

Lau H, Khosrawipour T, Kocbach P, Ichii H, Bania J,

Khosrawipour V. Evaluating the massive underreporting and

undertesting of COVID-19 cases in multiple global epicenters.

Pulmonology. 2021;27:110-15.

Prem K, Liu Y, Russell TW, Kucharski AJ, Eggo RM, Davies N,

et al. The effect of control strategies to reduce social mixing

on outcomes of the COVID‑19 epidemic in Wuhan, China:

A modelling study. Lancet Public Health 2020;5:e261‑70.

Bayham J, Fenichel EP. The impact of school closure for

COVID‑19 on the US healthcare workforce and the net mortality

effects. Available from: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.

cfm?abstract_id=3555259. [Last accessed on 2021 Mar 28].

Mayurasakorn K, Pinsawas B, Mongkolsucharitkul P,

Sranacharoenpong K, Damapong SN. School closure, COVID-19

and lunch programme: Unprecedented undernutrition crisis

in low-middle income countries. J Paediatr Child Health

;56:1013‑7.

Auger KA, Shah SS, Richardson T, Hartley D, Hall M,

Warniment A, et al. Association between statewide school

closure and COVID‑19 incidence and mortality in the US.

JAMA 2020;324:859‑70.

Kim S, Kim YJ, Peck KR, Jung E. School opening delay effect

on transmission dynamics of coronavirus disease 2019 in Korea:

Based on mathematical modeling and simulation study. J Korean

Med Sci 2020;35:e143.

Heavey L, Casey G, Kelly C, Kelly D, McDarby G. No evidence

of secondary transmission of COVID‑19 from children attending

school in Ireland, 2020. Eurosurveillance 2020;25:2000903.

Nunan D, Brassey J. What is the evidence for mass gatherings

during global pandemics?. Available from: https://www.cebm.

net/covid-19/what-is-the-evidence-for-mass-gatherings-duringglobal-pandemics/. [Last accessed on 2021 Mar 28].

Ebrahim SH, Memish ZA. COVID‑19 ‑ The role of mass

gatherings. Travel Med Infect Dis 2020;34:101617.

Che Mat NF, Edinur HA, Abdul Razab MKA, Safuan S. A single

mass gathering resulted in massive transmission of COVID‑19

infections in Malaysia with further international spread. J Travel

Med 2020;27:taaa059.

Escher AR Jr. An ounce of prevention: Coronavirus (COVID‑19)

and mass gatherings. Cureus 2020;12:e7345.

Chinazzi M, Davis JT, Ajelli M, Gioannini C, Litvinova M,

Merler S, et al. The effect of travel restrictions on the spread

of the 2019 novel coronavirus (COVID‑19) outbreak. Science

;368:395‑400.

Kakimoto K, Kamiya H, Yamagishi T, Matsui T, Suzuki M,

Wakita T. Initial investigation of transmission of COVID‑19

among crew members during quarantine of a cruise

ship ‑ Yokohama, Japan, February 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal

Wkly Rep 2020;69:312‑3.

Botes WM, Thaldar DW. COVID‑19 and quarantine orders:

A practical approach. S Afr Med J 2020;110:1‑4.

Howard J, Huang A, Li Z, Tufekci Z, Zdimal V, van der

Westhuizen HM, et al. An evidence review of face masks against

COVID-19. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2021;118:e2014564118.

doi: 10.1073/pnas.2014564118.

Greenhalgh T, Schmid MB, Czypionka T, Bassler D, Gruer L.

Face masks for the public during the covid‑19 crisis. BMJ

;369:m1435.

Lan J, Song Z, Miao X, Li H, Li Y, Dong L, et al. Skin damage

among health care workers managing coronavirus disease‑2019.

J Am Acad Dermatol 2020;82:1215‑6.

Parhar HS, Tasche K, Brody RM, Weinstein GS,

O’Malley BW Jr, Shanti RM, et al. Topical preparations to

reduce SARS‑CoV‑2 aerosolization in head and neck mucosal

surgery. Head Neck 2020;42:1268‑72.

British Broadcasting Corporation. Australia records zero

COVID‑19 cases for first time in five months. Available from:

https://www.bbc.com/news/world‑australia‑54768038. [Last

accessed on 2021 Mar 28].

Kung S, Doppen M, Black M, Hills T, Kearns N. Reduced

mortality in New Zealand during the COVID‑19 pandemic.

Lancet 2021;397:25.

Claeson M, Hanson S. COVID‑19 and the Swedish enigma.

Lancet 2021;397:259‑61.

Ansah JP, Matchar DB, Shao Wei SL, Low JG, Pourghaderi AR,

Siddiqui FJ, et al. The effectiveness of public health interventions

against COVID‑19: Lessons from the Singapore experience.

PLoS One 2021;16:e0248742.

Lee T, Kwon HD, Lee J. The effect of control measures

on COVID‑19 transmission in South Korea. PLoS One

;16:e0249262.